More

    Ashes 2025: What is Snicko? Why is it used in Australia? Why is it controversial? – BBC

    The Snickometer, commonly known as 'Snicko', is a decision-making technology system used to determine whether a batter has hit the ball during a video review.
    The technology shows replays in frame by frame pictures with a waveform created to display if there has been contact between bat and ball.
    It was invented by English computer scientist Allan Plaskett during the mid-1990s, but it is no longer used in Tests in England.
    Snicko has caused controversy during this Ashes series, with Australian batter Alex Carey given not out in the third Test due to "human error" by Snicko's operators. Carey was 72 not out at the time of incident and went on to make 106 in the first innings in Adelaide.
    Send us your questions
    England wicketkeeper Jamie Smith was also controversially dismissed following a Snicko review on day two of the third Test
    Broadcasters in Australia and New Zealand both use Snicko, while their counterparts in England, India and South Africa all use the more developed UltraEdge technology invented by Hawk Eye.
    UK broadcaster Sky Sports stopped using Snicko in 2016 due to the increased detail and accuracy that is made available by UltraEdge.
    UltraEdge gives the third umpire access to tracking cameras which can analyse up to 340 frames per second, providing more accurate information.
    Fox Sports, Australia's host broadcaster, has opted to use Snicko instead of UltraEdge for the series.
    Former England bowler Alex Hartley also said "Snicko needs to be sacked" during day two
    Host broadcasters have the option to select either UltraEdge or Snicko as sound-based edge detection technology, which are both approved for use by the International Cricket Board (ICC).
    The ICC themselves do not pay for the Decision Review System (DRS) outside of their tournaments – such as the T20 or 50-over World Cups.
    In the Ashes, the choice of technology is selected by and paid for by the host broadcaster, who will make their decision based on their budgets.
    Channel Seven and Foxtel reportedly paid £750m for the rights to show the sport in Australia until 2031 – a 10.5 per cent per year increase on the previous deal.
    Last year, the England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) paid for the technology for the first time as part of their broadcast deal with Sky.
    Costs between the two different technologies vary in each territory, but it is understood that UltraEdge is significantly more expensive to license than Snicko.
    Hot Spot is an infrared technology that uses heat sensors to highlight whether the ball has made contact with the bat.
    It is owned by the same company that also provides Snicko.
    It was abandoned by Australian broadcasters during 2013-14 Ashes series over concerns over its reliability and cost.
    The technology reportedly costs £6,000 per day to use.
    It also came under scrutiny during England's 3-0 Ashes victory in 2013 when several faint edges appeared to go undetected.
    Its inventor said its reliability is affected by the use of tape on bats and has not been used in Test cricket for a number of years.
    "We chose to use our money in other ways because of the criticisms of it," said Fox Cricket boss Steve Crawley in 2024.
    This video can not be played
    Carey survives England review for caught behind appeal as Snicko shows phantom spike
    At virtually the halfway point of this Ashes series, there have been several controversial incidents involving Snicko.
    The biggest controversy came when keeper-batter Carey was adjudged not out on review during the first day of the third Test in Adelaide.
    Carey later admitted he edged the delivery, but survived because the Snicko technology showed a discrepancy between the sound and pictures of the edge.
    Snicko used the sound captured by the stump microphone at the non-striker's end, rather than the striker's end.
    BBG, the company that provides Snicko, has admitted responsibility for the error.
    On day two, Australia's fielders could be heard saying "this could be anything" and "just review everything" in relation to Snicko decisions.
    Another fielder said "Snicko needs to be sacked" and was caught on the stump microphone.
    England wicketkeeper Jamie Smith was controversially dismissed on day two in the second Test in Brisbane following a questionable Snicko review for being caught behind.
    Smith was also controversially dismissed in the first Test in a similar incident, with Snicko showing a spike after the ball went past his bat.
    In the same Test, a similar incident happened involving Australia batter Marnus Labuschagne, although he was not given out due a lack of "conclusive evidence."
    Former England captain Michael Vaughan has been a vocal critic during the series and said he has "lost faith in the Snicko system".
    "It's a shocker. It's wrong. The players have lost trust in it," he told BBC Sport's Ashes Debrief.
    "The ICC need to look at themselves in the mirror because who pays for this? The host broadcaster aren't going to pay for the best technology, they pay so much for the rights. The home board aren't going to pay for it.
    "The ICC should be paying for whatever the best technology is. This is an ICC event, it's the World Test Championship."
    Former Australia captain Ricky Ponting echoed his former adversary and said the umpires had expressed concerns about its use.
    "This technology that we are using here is simply not as good as technology that is used in other countries," he told Seven Cricket.
    "You talk to the umpires, they'll tell you the same thing. They can't trust it."
    This video can not be played
    A tale of two balls – Double Snicko controversy as Smith given out
    It would be unprecedented for the use of Snicko to be scrapped mid-series given that it has been in use for the first three Tests.
    With the frustration shown by both teams, it is not out of the question that Australia may look to alternative technology in future home series.
    This article is the latest from BBC Sport's Ask Me Anything team.
    Who is Matthew Fisher and could he play in the third Test?
    Is batting getting harder in Australia?
    What is the Prime Minister's XI?
    What was the sandpaper scandal?
    'Pope has one innings to save his England place'
    A 'novice' who can 'punch a bit' – how good is Paul?
    Ecuador defender Pineida killed in shooting
    Preview the return of The Night Manager
    Get into the festive spirit with the mums (and Kevin)
    Andy Zaltzman poses a daily cricket conundrum about the Ashes
    The brand-new fantasy by Russell T Davies has surfaced
    'Pope has one innings to save his England place'
    A 'novice' who can 'punch a bit' – how good is Paul?
    I've realised I can make a difference – Hoy
    Why are Premier League shirts so expensive?
    Are English clubs ready for Champions League knockouts?
    No script, Joshua will quickly knock Paul out – Hearn
    Active aero and overtake mode – F1's new terminology
    How the Prem transfer market got hot
    Where does Old Trafford thriller rank among best Premier League games?
    Innovation, evolution, revolution – golf's new faces championing change
    'Felt like humiliation' – Egypt reacts to Salah's Liverpool row
    What fans, insiders and stats say about embattled Frank
    Vote for your Sports Personality Team of the Year
    Chiefs miss out & Packers' Parsons pain – NFL week 15 round-up
    Man City favourites and Liverpool in trouble – how WSL stands at winter break
    'There can only be one singer' – my secrets of successful man-management
    BBC Sports Personality of the Year 2025 contenders. Video
    'Mine was for social change, this is not' – King on Battle of the Sexes
    The man behind the headlines – Salah, by Klopp, Diaz and more
    Copyright © 2025 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.

    source

    Latest articles

    spot_imgspot_img

    Related articles

    Leave a reply

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    spot_imgspot_img